194 – Breaking News & Latest Updates 2026
Skip to main content

Sean Hollister

Sean Hollister

Senior Editor

Senior Editor

    More From Sean Hollister

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    My favorite Google codename and Epic’s favorite evidence: “Project Hug.”

    We’ve told you about Hug before, and now Epic’s telling the jury that 22 game developers “ultimately” made deals with Google that allegedly kept them from abandoning the Play Store, Bornstein claims.

    “Some of them told Google they were going to compete against the Play store, and Google paid them not to do so.”

    Bornstein admits “Google was too clever” to actually draw up contracts forcing devs not to compete with the Play Store but says Riot Games agreed not to compete.

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    Google caught in a lie about Play profits?

    Epic just showed us an apparent Google email where someone (not clear who) admitted Google was lying about not making money from Android apps.

    “We have previously said that we don’t make money from [Android Market, the previous name for Google Play]. We are now lying,” the email snippet read.

    Back in the day, Google said “we do not take a percentage.” Now, apps make Google $12 billion a year with a 70 percent profit margin, says Epic.

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    And we’re on to sideloading.

    Epic knows Google will argue that it’s an open platform where anyone can install apps without going to a store. So Epic is arguing Google makes it far too difficult — by labeling sideloaded apps “unknown” and making you jump through hoops (see image below).

    “Fortnite was the biggest game in the world, Google knew it was not an unknown app,” says Bornstein. “Google called it unknown so it could put up warnings just like those.”

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    “Everyone else is forced to run in quicksand.”

    Epic’s attorney Gary Bornstein, arguing that Google also blocks competing app stores and payment mechanisms.

    “They’re not allowed to use their power to stop everyone from trying. The law draws a line.”

    He says he’ll also show evidence during the trial that Google knows its up to 30 percent cut of Android app transactions is too high.

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    “Bribe or block.”

    Argues Epic: “Google has such extraordinary power over android phones that it can use two strategies to prevent all other competition and maintain those big green bars. Here is what those strategies are: bribe or block.”

    “Google pays actual and potential competitors not to compete. Literally gives them money and other things of value.”

    “It’s like Google saying here’s $360 million — that’s an actual number you’ll hear about — why don’t you sit this one out and let me win?”

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    Epic starts with a chart.

    Epic’s lead attorney Gary Bornstein’s opening argument revolves around green bars — 12 of them, representing the months January–December 2020, showing the Google Play Store counts for well over 90 percent of app installs on Android that year.

    Bornstein says Google will argue that the Samsung app store comes installed on 60 percent of all phones, but it’s only an orange sliver on the chart.

    “That is all that Samsung, the largest OEM by far, has been able to achieve.”

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    It’s time for opening arguments in the Epic v. Google trial.

    Epic is up first. Here we go.

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    The Epic Google jury has to rely on their own memory of the courtroom.

    Judge Donato says the jury won’t get transcripts of what witnesses said. Also: “You should rely on your own memory of the evidence,” not notes, though they are allowed to take handwritten notes during the trial.

    Jurors can ask clarifying questions during trial; they can’t speak to anyone else, though, so you won’t see me chasing down a juror for an interview.

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    BTW, it’s kind of a big deal that we’ve got a jury here today.

    When Epic took on Apple, it was a “bench trial” — a judge decided the whole thing, mostly in Apple’s favor. Now, a fairly similar case is going before a jury. Might they decide differently?

    Sean Hollister
    Sean Hollister
    An Epic jury is getting instructed.

    For example: “You must follow the law as I give it to you, regardless of whether or not you agree with it.”

    “You must decide the case solely based on the evidence before you.”

    If you want to see what jury instructions look like, these were the proposed jury instructions for this trial.